Are Helical Pile Foundations The Ultimate Support for Battery Energy Storage?

New York state has big goals for expanding energy storage capacity. Could helical foundations be a solution for building it faster, easier, and cleaner?

Illustration

Introduction

Battery energy storage (BESS) has been getting a lot of attention over the past several years here in New York. In fact, the rather lengthily-named New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA) has set a goal to achieve 6,000 MW of energy storage capacity by 2030.
As the shift towards a new mix of traditional and renewable power sources continues, building this battery energy storage capacity is enormously important if we want a stable and reliable electric grid.
But, this rapid growth in BESS leads us to a big challenge...
...how can we meet the demand for this infrastructure while keeping projects profitable, timely, and friendly for environment?
Sure, concrete foundations have been a classic go-to solution. But is their slow installation, extensive site prep, and considerable environmental impact, really the best solution for energy storage construction here in Central New York?

Illustration

We'd argue there's a better foundation option than concrete: helical piles.
This under-appreciated foundation has been quietly revolutionizing how battery energy storage is built in the Southern U.S. and West Coast.
Unfortunately, they haven't quite taken-off here in Central New York.
Since there's nothing worse than a missed opportunity, we decided to unpack why you should consider using a helical pile foundation to support battery energy storage units.
From faster installation to minimal site disturbance and outstanding performance in harsh soil conditions, we're pulling-back the curtain on helical piles and exploring why they've become the foundation of choice for countless BESS projects.
If you're going to be planning, managing, building, or owning, an energy storage installation, you owe it to yourself to keep reading. Join us as we take a clear look at how helical piles are reshaping the nature of BESS construction!

All About Helical Piles For Battery Storage Units

Illustration

The first thing you need to know about helical piles is that, despite a common misconception, they are not a foundation that's only suitable for light loads. We don't know where that idea came from, but it's completely untrue.
Helical piles, also known as screw piles, are a deep foundation technology that offers an alternative to typical concrete or driven pile solutions. At the core, a helical pile consists of two key elements:
● A central steel shaft made from round pipe or solid square bar● One (or more) helical-shaped plates welded along the shaft
These plates have two key jobs:
1: Allow the pile to be installed by smoothly rotating into the ground (kind of like a giant screw)
2: Deliver enormous bearing capacity by using surrounding soil pressure to anchor it in-place

Illustration

How is a Helical Pile for Energy Storage Installed?

Illustration

Installing a helical pile foundation is a straightforward and simple process. Although each specific project might have variations in what this process looks like, it generally goes something like this:

1: Design the Foundation

This first step is the most important one for your project - devising a solid and efficient design for your foundation. Thanks to the fact there's a wide range of helical pile sizes and configurations available, we're able to precisely adjust it to match your exact needs. No 'one size fits all' solutions here!
By assessing key factors like structural loads and soil conditions, we're able to fine-tune the helical piles so you're not paying for more (or getting less) than required.

2: Mobilize to Site

With a concrete foundation, it's going to require the mobilization of heavy equipment and plenty of raw materials to your site. From accommodating staging areas to scheduling lines of concrete trucks, this phase can bring delays and frustrations.
Helical piles, conversely, require a fraction of the machines or materials. Installation is done using standard excavators, the piles stack nicely on a trailer (while taking little space on-site), and you don't have to worry about line of concrete trucks.

3: Install Helical Piles

In all honesty, actually installing a helical pile can be a bit anticlimactic because it's so darn easy. A pile is first secured to an anchor drive which is attached to the excavator. After careful positioning, we apply rotational force and downward crowd to "spin" the pile into the ground at a constant rate.
If a pile needs to go deeper, we can quickly add extensions and continue the installation. Repeat until all the piles are firmly in place!

Unlocking Real-Time Quality Control With Helical Piles

Illustration

One of the aspects about installing a helical pile that really sets it apart from other foundation solutions comes down to torque.
Specifically, the way we can use torque to perform real-time quality control on each and every pile.
Since we're applying rotational force to a helical pile during installation, we can read those forces as torque.
Using torque-to-capacity calculations that have been devised and proven by researchers, we can gain information about a pile's expected load capacity and performance. In essence, by monitoring installation torque, we can directly correlate it to the number of pounds (kips) each pile should be able to hold.

Why Reading Helical Pile Torque Makes for a Better BESS Foundation

Illustration

Let's illustrate the power of the torque-to-capacity calculation with an example.
Imagine the geotech report for your site indicates dense clay at a depth of 20 feet. Based on that information, we calculate each pile will need to achieve at least 8,000 ft-lbs of torque in order to meet the required load capacity.
But, during installation, we find the soils at 20 feet are in fact not dense clay but some weaker material.
Thanks to the fact we're constantly reading torque, we'll know instantly that those piles will need to go deeper in order to reach stronger soils. So, we add extensions and sink the piles to 30 feet - where we ultimately reach the correct torque.
This turns what could have been a major delay into nothing more than a brief blip. It gives you confidence in the performance of your foundation and prevents frustrating setbacks when unexpected soil conditions appear.

How Do Helical Piles Compare to Concrete for BESS?

Illustration

Okay, you might be thinking this sounds pretty good so far, but how do helical piles compare to concrete? After all, concrete has been the foundation solution for battery storage units for years - why even make the switch to helical piles?
Let's see how the two foundation options stack-up against each other on some key points...

1. Site Preparation & Install

    Helical Piles: Mark pile locations, ensure area is cleared of obstructions, rotate piles into ground.
    Concrete: Clear site, auger holes, dewater, set rebar/forms, pour, backfill, grade, haul tailings/spoils away.

2. Installation Time

    Helical Piles: Can be installed and ready in as little as a single day.
    Concrete: Installation can take several days, plus 1 - 2 weeks for proper curing

3. Performance

    Helical Piles: Big load capacities in a compact footprint. Resists soil movement.
    Concrete: Large load capacities, but also requires a larger footprint. Is more prone to shifting and heaving along with the soil.

4. Strength & Durability

    Helical Piles: Made from steel, can be galvanized if needed, lasts for 75 to 100+ years even in harsh soils.
    Concrete: When properly mixed and poured, last around 75 years. Harsh soil or climate conditions can quicken degradation and shorten their lifespan.

5. Overall Economy

    Helical Piles: Can have higher upfront material costs, which is offset by faster installation, reduced site prep, and fewer labor requirements.
    Concrete: Generally has lower material costs - but can take longer to install, site prep is more extensive, excavation leaves a mess.

6. Environmental Impact

    Helical Piles: Minimal site disturbance, less raw materials required, reduces embodied carbon, can be easily removed and recycled.
    Concrete: Extensive ground disruption, large amount of raw materials consumed, higher embodied carbon, difficult to remove and cannot be recycled.

So, what's the verdict?

First, it's important to note that concrete isn't a "bad' option. We're not out to attack it - but we do think it's important to be honest about its shortcomings.

Illustration

Concrete is a great building material, but is it the best foundation material for energy storage units?

Helical piles offer a quick, efficient, and environmentally friendly foundation solution. Yes, the initial cost may be higher than concrete. But considering the time saved and long-term performance, they're often a more economical choice overall.

Besides, if you're already spending money on BESS units, adding a little more budget for the foundation ensures your investment is protected for decades to come.

Why Use A Helical Foundation for Energy Storage?

Illustration
  • Fast Installation

    Helical piles can be installed and ready to use over 90% faster than concrete. This reduces project timelines and gets you up-and-running sooner.

  • Minimal Site Prep

    Unlike concrete, helical piles require no excavation (unless pile tops need to sit below grade). This minimizes site disturbance, cleanup, and disruption, to existing infrastructure.

  • Material Efficiency

    Helical piles use significantly less raw material than concrete foundations, streamlining installation and slashing your project's environmental impact.

  • Artboard 30

    Lower Carbon Footprint

    With the aforementioned reduced material use, helical piles have a far smaller carbon footprint than a comparable concrete foundation.

  • Easy Remediation

    Need to modify or remove the foundation someday? Helical piles can be easily extracted and even reused (on engineer's approval), making remediation or renovations a snap.

  • Versatility

    Whether you're dealing with sand, clay, mud, or even rocky soils, helical piles readily adapt to deliver superior performance in a range of ground conditions.

Conclusion

Illustration

The energy storage industry has seen massive growth in the United States, and it shows no signs of changing anytime soon.

Helical pile foundations are transforming how energy storage is built in the United States. In many areas it's becoming the default foundation choice for new projects thanks to its speed, strength, and ease of use.

Concrete will always have its place in construction. But, as a foundation for energy storage applications, we believe helical piles offer clear advantages. Not the least of which is their ability to help you build sooner, minimize your environmental footprint, and enjoy the confidence of lasting performance.

Want to learn more about helical piles and see if they're a good fit for your project? Our team at CDP Excavating is here to help!

We're happy to offer insights into the technology, answer your questions, and provide an estimate for your project.

(No clingy salespeople or endless "just checking in" phone calls!)

Get in touch today and let's find out if a helical foundation is the solid solution for your battery energy storage project.

Author Information

  • Illustration

    This post was written by the team at CDP Excavating, using our 17+ years of experience operating in Central New York. CDP Excavating is run by Jason Perry, whose passion for big projects and working with the earth goes back to his childhood. Independently-owned and family-run, we offer high-quality helical pile foundation services to engineers, contractors, homeowners, and more.

Questions About What You Just Read?

Have questions about using helical pile foundations for your battery energy storage project in Central New York? Get in touch with our friendly team to learn more.

Contact Info

(315) 430-0048moc.gnitavacxepdc%40olleh

Hours

Monday - Friday 9 AM - 5 PM

Thank you for getting in touch!

We will review your message and be in contact within 2 business days

Can't send form.

Please try again later.

Areas That CDP Excavating Serves in Central New York

Albion, Amboy, Baldwinsville, Boylston, Camillus, Central Square, Cicero, Clay, Cleveland, Constantia, DeWitt, Fabius, Fulton, Geddes, Granby, Hannibal, Hastings, Lacona, Lafayette, Lysander, Manlius, Marcellus, Mexico, Minetto, New Haven, Onondaga, Orwell, Oswego, Otisco, Palermo, Parish, Phoenix, Pompey, Pulaski, Redfield, Richland, Salina, Sandy Creek, Schroeppel, Scriba, Skaneateles, Stafford, Tully, Vanburen, Volney, West Monroe, Williamstown